The Difference between Wirecard and Steinhoff

Wirecard and Steinhoff are both companies of German origin which had accounting scandals. In this post I want to describe why these two accounting scandals are completely different and why I choose to take a long position in Steinhoff after the scandal, although I did make a profit with a short position in Wirecard.

I am writing this article because I want to describe that shorting a stock with an accounting scandal / fraud isn’t always the best option. Sometimes this can be a chance for a long position.

The Wirecard Scandal

In 2020 it was reported in an audit that €1.9 billion were “missing”. I shorted Wirecard after the announcement because it meant that the majority of Wirecards revenue didn’t exist while there were multiple billion Euro of credit from banks.

I realized that there was a way higher debt to the creditors than actual revenue or profit which could pay for the credit, so there was no real way that Wirecard could save itself from insolvency.

Also, Wirecard is a payments provider used by companies — which company does trust a payment provider which manipulates balance sheets?

The Steinhoff Scandal

Basically the scandal which took off in 2017 was that Steinhoff manipulated transactions worth of $7.36 billion from the years 2009 to 2017.

Now comes one important part: The revenue alone in 2017 was nearly 19 billion Euro!!! Even if you subtract all manipulated transactions from that there is still value!

Steinhoff also is a holding company which holds many different companies which can be sold. That’s what happened after the scandal: Many subsidiaries were sold.

The Difference

  • Wirecard made up most of the revenue
  • Steinhoff didn’t made up most, but part of the revenue

From the strategic side:

  • Wirecard was basically one company which hadn’t much to sell
  • Steinhoff had many companies with actual real estate and products — many things to sell

My Opinion

I shorted Wirecard because there was noting to hope. With basically all revenue made up there is no real revenue which could help paying the credits down.

You should look at the actual numbers after an accounting scandal. I also know there were investigations about an accounting issue at GE, but I didn’t see it effecting the share price too much — because the numbers in question were too small.

Putting all accounting scandals into the same bucket is wrong, but I experienced that happens.

(To be honest I was laughing my ass off because there are German finance influencers which always talked bad about Investors in Steinhoff but then were heavily invested in Wirecard, didn’t see that scandal coming and even invested after there were many signs that the balance sheet was faked)

Software Developer and Investor from Germany. Writing about Software, Tech and Investments.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store